Issue 02 · UK sole-trader tax and compliance
Making Tax Digital for Income Tax: who is in, when, and what it costs
HMRC's own guidance and statistics, and the National Audit Office's audit, read side by side.
The bottom line
- If you are a sole trader or landlord whose self-employment and property income before expenses was over £30,000 in the 2025 to 2026 tax year, HMRC says you will need to use Making Tax Digital for Income Tax from 6 April 2027. T1T2 Verified
- That means digital records, four quarterly updates a year and a tax return through compatible software. Late quarterly updates in the 2026 to 2027 tax year carry no penalty points; later years do. T3 Verified
- The independent audit evidence is older and critical: in 2023 the NAO found the scheme at least eight years late and its costs underestimated in HMRC's business cases. No independent evaluation of the new system's first year exists yet. T7 Hypothesised
What the sources say
Findings by theme
Who has to join, and when
- VerifiedYou need to use it if you are a sole trader or landlord registered for Self Assessment, get self-employment or property income, and your qualifying income is over the threshold. T1
- VerifiedThe thresholds step down: over £50,000 in 2024 to 2025 means starting 6 April 2026; over £30,000 in 2025 to 2026 means 6 April 2027; over £20,000 in 2026 to 2027 means 6 April 2028. T1
- VerifiedQualifying income is total self-employment plus property income before expenses. Employment pay, dividends, pensions and a partnership profit share do not count. HMRC's example: £25,000 rent plus £27,000 self-employment gives £52,000. T2
- VerifiedHMRC checks your previous return and writes to you, but if no letter arrives it is still your responsibility to check and sign up. T1
- VerifiedYou are automatically exempt if your qualifying income is £20,000 or less. Partnerships do not need to join yet, and people who are digitally excluded can apply for an exemption. T5
What you actually have to do
- VerifiedKeep digital records in compatible software and send quarterly updates by 7 August, 7 November, 7 February and 7 May, then a tax return by 31 January after the tax year. T3
- Verified
Penalties under the new rules
- VerifiedLate submissions earn points. At 4 points you get a £200 penalty, and another £200 for each further missed deadline. You only get one point per deadline, even with several businesses. T3
- VerifiedLate payment: nothing up to 15 days late. For the 2027 to 2028 tax year, 4% of the tax owed at day 15, another 4% at day 30, then 10% a year charged daily from day 31. In your first year you get 30 days before penalties start. T3
- EstimatedWorked example: £2,000 of tax for 2027 to 2028 paid 20 days late, outside your first year, would mean a 4% penalty at day 15 of £80. T3
How many people this touches
- EstimatedHMRC counts 7.0 million people in Self Assessment with sole-trader or landlord income in 2023 to 2024. Around 2.9 million (42%) have qualifying income above £20,000. T6
- EstimatedOn 2023 to 2024 figures: 864,000 over £50,000 (from April 2026), 1,077,000 between £30,000 and £50,000 (April 2027) and 975,000 between £20,000.01 and £30,000 (April 2028). T6
- VerifiedAmong those over £50,000, 75% had an agent and 63% already filed with software. Of those with an agent, 78% used commercial software, against 21% without one. T6
The audit record: delays and costs
- VerifiedIn June 2023 the NAO found MTD for Self Assessment at least eight years behind its original timetable, after a fourth delay in December 2022. T7
- EstimatedHMRC's estimated programme costs rose from £226 million in 2016 to £1.3 billion, a 400% real-terms increase. T7
- EstimatedHMRC's 2021 research put upfront costs at an average of £330 per business affected, and almost £1,000 for some. T7
- VerifiedThe 2017 pilot ended with only 15 participants when it closed to new entrants in 2022. T7
Where they disagree
Debates and contradictions
Is MTD worth what it costs?
Is software a real burden for sole traders?
How much to trust it
Quality of the evidence
| Claim | Evidence | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Who must join, and when | Strong | Stated directly in current HMRC guidance, updated in 2026. T1T5 Verified |
| How many people are affected | Moderate | Official statistics, but based on 2023 to 2024 returns; actual numbers depend on future years' income. T6 Verified |
| MTD costs more than it raises | Inconclusive | The only independent estimate is a June 2023 audit of an earlier design; nothing since the launch. T7 Hypothesised |
What nobody has measured yet
Research gaps
Practical gap
There is no published evaluation of how the first 2026 cohort coped with quarterly updates. T4 Hypothesised
Open question (ours): What share of the April 2026 cohort sent each quarterly update on time, and what predicted lateness?
Methodological gap
Cost-to-taxpayer figures come from HMRC's 2021 research, before the current phased design. T7 Verified
Open question (ours): What do sole traders actually spend on software and agent fees in their first MTD year?
Population gap
Population counts are based on 2023 to 2024 returns, not the years that set each start date. T6 Verified
Open question (ours): How many people cross the £30,000 line on their 2025 to 2026 returns?
Contextual gap
Partnerships' timeline is still unannounced. T1 Verified
Open question (ours): When will partnerships be brought in, and on what threshold?
If you run a small business
What this means in practice
- Add up your 2025 to 2026 self-employment and property turnover now. If it is over £30,000, plan for a 6 April 2027 start, whether or not a letter arrives. T1T2 Hypothesised
- Pick software before April, not after, so your records are digital from day one of your update period. T4 Hypothesised
- Put the four update dates and 31 January in your calendar. The no-points year for quarterly updates covers 2026 to 2027 only. T3 Verified
Where the sources are thin. Thin spots: the only independent evaluation (NAO) dates from June 2023, the population figures use 2023 to 2024 returns, and there is no public data yet on how the April 2026 cohort is coping. Check GOV.UK before acting: the guidance pages were updated as recently as 12 November 2026.
How this brief was made
We fetched 7 public sources on 16 November 2026 and saved their text. We then ran these prompts from our source-grounded prompt pack: 1. Structured literature review; 3. Debates and contradictions; 4. Research gaps; 6. Synthesis by theme; 7. Quality of the evidence. Answers use only those sources.
Before publishing, an automated check confirmed that each of the 61 claims cites a source and carries a truth label, that all 116 supporting quotes appear word for word in the saved source text, that every number in a claim appears in its quotes (or is a worked calculation that we recompute), and that every source link resolves.
Sources
Sources
- T1HMRC (2026a). Find out if and when you need to use Making Tax Digital for Income Tax. GOV.UK. Official guidance. https://www.gov.uk/guidance/find-out-if-and-when-you-need-to-use-making-tax-digital-for-income-tax. Accessed 16 Nov 2026.
- T2HMRC (2026b). Work out your qualifying income for Making Tax Digital for Income Tax. GOV.UK. Official guidance. https://www.gov.uk/guidance/work-out-your-qualifying-income-for-making-tax-digital-for-income-tax. Accessed 16 Nov 2026.
- T3HMRC (2026c). Penalties for Making Tax Digital for Income Tax. GOV.UK. Official guidance. https://www.gov.uk/guidance/penalties-for-making-tax-digital-for-income-tax. Accessed 16 Nov 2026.
- T4HMRC (2026d). Using Making Tax Digital for Income Tax for the first time. GOV.UK. Official guidance. https://www.gov.uk/guidance/use-making-tax-digital-for-income-tax/using-making-tax-digital-for-income-tax-for-the-first-time. Accessed 16 Nov 2026.
- T5HMRC (2026e). Find out if you can get an exemption from Making Tax Digital for Income Tax. GOV.UK. Official guidance. https://www.gov.uk/guidance/find-out-if-you-can-get-an-exemption-from-making-tax-digital-for-income-tax. Accessed 16 Nov 2026.
- T6HMRC (2025). Making Tax Digital for Income Tax business population statistics: commentary. GOV.UK (official statistics). Official statistics, tax year 2023 to 2024. https://www.gov.uk/government/statistics/making-tax-digital-for-income-tax-business-population-statistics/making-tax-digital-for-income-tax-business-population-statistics-commentary. Accessed 16 Nov 2026.
- T7NAO (2023). Progress with Making Tax Digital (HC 1319, Session 2022-23). NAO. Independent audit report. https://www.nao.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/progress-with-making-tax-digital.pdf. Accessed 16 Nov 2026.